My Training Studio vs Square Appointments

Square Appointments is a great free scheduling tool. We are studio operations software. The moment you sell your first session package, you will outgrow Square Appointments. Every plan includes unlimited clients.

A scheduling tool is not a studio tool

Square Appointments is exactly what its name says. A calendar, basic payments, simple appointment reminders. Free for one user. For a solo PT just starting out, it is genuinely excellent. Book a session, take a card after, repeat.

A session package is the unit of a personal training business. If your software does not model packages, it does not model your business.

The moment you sell a 12-session package, hire a second trainer, or want to track who's about to run out of sessions, the gap shows. Square has no concept of packages, contracts, FIFO drawdown, commissions, or retention. We were built around those.

Where each tool actually wins

Square Appointments is a fine starting tool. We are the studio software you graduate to.

My Training StudioSquare Appointments
Booking and Scheduling
1-on-1 session booking Yes Yes
Online client self-booking Yes Yes
Trainer-specific availability + conflict detection YesBasic
Recurring weekly sessions from contract Yes No
Session Packages and Contracts
Session packages with balance tracking Yes No
FIFO drawdown across overlapping packages Yes No
Contract-to-schedule linking Yes No
Sessions-remaining alerts Yes No
Studio Operations
Trainer commission tracking Yes No
Trainer payouts Yes No
Retention and attendance reports Yes No
Square Appointments' Core Strengths
Free for solo trainer (1 user)$50/mo solo Free
Built-in card reader and POS No Yes
Square ecosystem (POS, payroll, gift cards) No Yes
Payments
You own the merchant account Your StripeSquare is the merchant
Recurring billing rate2.9% + $0.303.5% + $0.15
Take payment data with you if you leave Yes No

What this looks like in your studio

Three things Square Appointments does not have. We treat them as core.

YOUR STUDIO · Contract
Sarah M. · 2x/week Package
18
Used
6
Scheduled
Session packages with FIFO drawdown. Square has no concept of a package.
YOUR STUDIO · Payouts
March 2026
TrainerSessionsRevenueCommission
Coach Dan42$3,150$945
Coach Lia28$2,100$630
Coach Marc18$1,350$405
Total commission$1,980
One-click trainer payouts. Square Appointments has no commission concept.
YOUR STUDIO · Retention Report
ClientSessionsMonthsStatus
Sarah Mitchell14814Active
Lisa Kim8711Active
Mike Rodriguez626Active
Tom Watson343Inactive
See who's drifting before they cancel. No equivalent in Square Appointments.

Free is hard to beat. Wrong tool is worse.

Square Appointments is free for one user. We are not. We are also not a scheduling tool.

Your businessMy Training StudioSquare Appointments
Solo trainer$50/moFree
2-staff studio$199/mo$29/mo + $20/staff
5-staff studio$199/mo$69/mo + $35/staff
Session packages, contracts, FIFOAll includedNot modeled
Trainer commissions and payoutsIncludedNot modeled
Recurring payment processing2.9% + $0.30 (your Stripe)3.5% + $0.15 (Square)

Square Appointments tier prices are public on squareup.com/appointments. The pattern that matters: they price for a scheduling tool, we price for studio software.

Which one is for you?

Pick Square Appointments if...

  • You are a solo PT just getting started. Free is the right price.
  • You charge a card after every session. No packages, no contracts, no recurring.
  • You already use Square's POS / card reader / payroll and ecosystem matters.
  • You do not have multiple trainers and do not pay commissions.

Pick My Training Studio if...

  • You sell session packages, even just 5-packs and 10-packs.
  • You want unlimited clients on every plan with no per-client fees.
  • You have, or are about to add, a second trainer.
  • You want to own your Stripe account, not have Square hold your funds.
  • You want retention and attendance reports out of the box.

Common questions

Is Square Appointments enough for a personal training studio?

Square Appointments is a scheduling tool with basic payment processing. It works well for a solo PT who books 1-on-1 sessions and charges a card after each session. The moment you sell a session package, hire a second trainer, or want to track retention, you will hit the limits. Square has no concept of session packages, FIFO drawdown across packages, contracts, trainer commissions, or retention reporting. My Training Studio is built around those primitives.

How much does Square Appointments cost vs My Training Studio?

Square Appointments is free for 1 user, $29/mo plus $20 per staff member for the Plus tier, and $69/mo plus $35 per staff for Premium. My Training Studio starts at $50/mo solo and is $199/mo for up to 5 trainers with unlimited clients. Square wins on sticker price for tiny studios. MTS wins on what your business actually needs once you sell packages or hire trainers.

Does Square Appointments handle session packages?

No. Square Appointments has no native concept of a session package or a multi-session contract. You can sell items in Square's POS, but the platform does not track sessions remaining, draw down a balance on attendance, or alert you when a client is running out. My Training Studio treats session packages as a core primitive with FIFO drawdown across overlapping packages.

You will outgrow Square Appointments

The moment you sell a session package, you will feel the gap. Let's talk before that happens.

Request a Demo